I think holding on to both is the best option right now . If I could,pick only one...you have to go with stlye or preferences . The 87 accuracy guy will be better at kicking today under 44 yards , but the boomer will be better at kickoffs and mabye longer FGs. Still, he's only at 83 kick strength now . Idk who will have the highest accuracy in the end but neither will be elite .
Rookie kickers are a liability at best anyway. So, to me a better defense might prefer the weak leg and a worse offense might prefer the stronger leg. Something like that would drive my decision